Suda On Line menu Search

Home
Search results for phi,653 in Adler number:
Greek display:    

Headword: *fwnh/
Adler number: phi,653
Translated headword: utterance, voice
Vetting Status: high
Translation:
[Note] that an utterance [is] a type of sound. An utterance is a striking of air or air being struck. For not every sound is an utterance, just as a sound coming from inanimate things like waves or winds is not an utterance.[1] But an utterance is a sound of an animate being, even though not every sound of an animate being is an utterance. Neither clapping the hands nor clearing one's throat or coughing [is an utterance]. For an utterance is a sound of an animate being, made by means of the vocal parts,[2] such as the sounds made by the lungs and the respiratory parts: both the rough artery and the windpipe.[3] And [an utterance] is not made when a sound is produced by these things in just any manner. That is why it is said that the one who is coughing does not make an utterance. However, when these things are set in motion accompanied by a bodily representation,[4] then, the sound produced by these is called an utterance. [...] The following three things are observed with regard to human utterance: (i) rhythm, (ii) harmony, (iii) diction. (i) Rhythm is concerned with time (long or short) of pronunciation.[5] For this reason, among vowels [fwnhe/nta], those that are uttered for more time are also denominated long, while those that are uttered for less time are called short. And the appropriate rhythm of words arises from the mutual composition of these things. (ii) Harmony is concerned with symmetry of the high and the low [pitch]. (iii) Diction is concerned with the configuration of syllables, by which the concept of the spoken things is signified. Now since human utterance has these things in a proper sense, but musical instruments also in a certain sense imitate them, because of this they also are said by analogy to make utterance.
[Note] that they[6] distinguish utterance from sound in two ways: by the mode of its generation and by its purpose. Now by the mode of its generation because utterance arises when the inhaled air is squeezed out by a contraction of the chest according to the psychic power inherent in it and falls upon the rough artery and the air enclosed in it. Such air rebounding at one stroke continually hits the adjacent air, reaching the hearing. For the empty part of the mouth up to the root of the tongue is the windpipe. From that place two cavities extend: the one, which is also called artery, toward the chest; the other in the sinew, which is called gullet [oi)sofa/gos], as well. [...] And the passing of the breath occurs through the rough artery, and such a passing happens both in inhaling and exhalation, which produces, according to the aforesaid mode, when it is breathed out a sound that is called utterance when it arises accompanied by a significant representation. Thus by the mode of its generation utterance differs from sounds in this fashion. [...] By the mode of its purpose [utterance differs from sound] because utterance arises from an impulse of the animal and connotes something. For that reason such an utterance is accompanied by a representation as well. Therefore, the sounds of the irrational animals are also utterances. [...] For a dog, when it has an impression of someone alien to it, barks, and when it has an impression of someone familiar to it, fawns. In the same way for the other animals also, utterances signify the psychic faculties and dispositions. For while desiring food or any other thing, they make use of utterance.
Greek Original:
*fwnh/: o(/ti ei)=dos h( fwnh\ tou= yo/fou. e)/sti de\ fwnh\ plh=cis a)e/ros, h)\ a)h\r peplhgme/nos. ou) ga\r pa=s yo/fos fwnh/, w(/sper ou)de\ o( e)k tw=n a)yu/xwn oi(=on kuma/twn h)\ a)ne/mwn gino/menos: a)ll' e)myu/xou tino\s yo/fos e)sti\n h( fwnh/. ou) mh\n de\ pa=s yo/fos e)myu/xou fwnh/: ou)de\ o( dia\ xeirw=n kro/tos ou)de\ to\ xre/myasqai ou)de\ to\ bh=cai: fwnh\ ga/r e)stin e)myu/xou yo/fos, dia\ tw=n fwnhtikw=n gino/menos mori/wn, oi(=on pneu/mono/s te kai\ tw=n a)napneustikw=n mori/wn, kai\ th=s traxei/as a)rthri/as kai\ th=s fa/ruggos. kai\ ou)de\ dia\ tou/twn o(pwsou=n tou= yo/fou ginome/nou, dio/per ou)de\ o( bh/ttwn le/getai fwnei=n: a)ll' o(/tan meta\ fantasi/as swmatikh=s tau=ta kinhqh=|, to/te o( gino/menos u(po\ tou/twn yo/fos fwnh\ kalei=tai. tri/a de\ tau=ta qewrei=tai peri\ th\n tou= a)nqrw/pou fwnh/n, r(uqmo/s, a(rmoni/a, le/cis. e)/xei de\ o( me\n r(uqmo\s peri\ to\n xro/non th=s e)kfwnh/sews to\n makro\n kai\ to\n braxu/n: dio\ kai\ tw=n fwnhe/ntwn ta\ me\n e)n plei/oni xro/nw| e)kfwnou/mena makra\ w)no/masan, ta\ de\ e)n e)la/ttoni braxe/a. e)k de\ th=s tou/twn pro\s a)/llhla sunqe/sews to\ eu)/ruqmon tw=n e)pw=n gi/netai. h( de\ a(rmoni/a peri\ th\n tou= o)ce/os kai\ bare/os summetri/an e)/xei, h( de\ le/cis peri\ th\n diatu/pwsin tw=n sullabw=n, e)c h(=s h( tw=n legome/nwn shmai/netai e)/nnoia. e)pei\ ou)=n tau=ta me\n e)/xei kuri/ws h( tou= a)nqrw/pou fwnh/, mimou=ntai de/ pws tau=ta kai\ ta\ mousika\ o)/rgana, dia\ tou=to kat' a)nalogi/an le/gontai kai\ au)ta\ fwnei=n. o(/ti diakri/nousi th\n fwnh\n a)po\ tou= yo/fou dixw=s, e)/k te tou= tro/pou th=s gene/sews kai\ e)k tou= te/lous. e)k me\n ou)=n tou= tro/pou th=s gene/sews, o(/ti h( fwnh\ gi/netai tou= ei)spneusqe/ntos a)e/ros e)kqlibome/nou th=| sustolh=| tou= qw/rakos kata\ th\n e)nupa/rxousan au)tw=| yuxikh\n du/namin kai\ prospi/ptontos th=| traxei/a| a)rthri/a| kai\ tw=| e)napeilhmme/nw| e)n au)th=| a)e/ri, o(\s th=| a)qro/a| plhgh=| a)/qruptos a)popallo/menos a)ei\ tu/ptei to\n prosexh= a)e/ra e(/ws th=s a)koh=s. e)/sti ga\r to\ me\n a)xane\s tou= sto/matos to\ me/xri th=s r(i/zhs th=s glw/tths fa/rugc: e)kei=qen du/o a)ggei=a fe/rontai, to\ me\n e)pi\ to\n qw/raka, kai\ kalei=tai a)rthri/a, to\ de\ e(/teron pro\s tw=| te/nonti, kai\ kalei=tai oi)sofa/gos. gi/netai de\ dia\ th=s traxei/as a)rthri/as h( pa/rodos tou= pneu/matos, h(/ te kata\ th\n ei)spomph\n kai\ th\n e)kpomph/n, o(/per tw=| ei)rhme/nw| tro/pw| e)kpneo/menon poiei= yo/fon, o(\s kalei=tai fwnh/, o(/tan meta/ tinos shmantikh=s fantasi/as gi/nhtai. e)k me\n ou)=n tou= tro/pou th=s gene/sews tau/th| diafe/rei h( fwnh\ tw=n yo/fwn. e)k de\ tou= te/lous, o(/ti h( fwnh\ kaq' o(rmh/n tina tou= zw/|ou gi/netai kai\ prosshmai/nei ti: dio\ kai\ meta\ fantasi/as. dio\ kai\ oi( tw=n a)lo/gwn yo/foi fwnai/. kai\ ga\r o( ku/wn, o(phni/ka fantasi/an e)/xei tou= a)llotri/ou, u(laktei=: o(/tan de\ tou= oi)kei/ou, sai/nei. kai\ e)pi\ tw=n a)/llwn zw/|wn w(sau/tws shmantikai/ ei)sin ai( fwnai\ tw=n yuxikw=n duna/mewn kai\ diaqe/sewn. kai\ ga\r trofh=s o)rego/mena h)\ a)/llou tino\s ke/xrhtai fwnh=|.
Notes:
Source (with slight changes): John Philoponus, Commentary on Aristotle's de anima 375.9-376.1 and [the second paragraph here] 378.29-379.15.
[1] The distinction between utterance or voice (phone) and sound (psophos) was widely discussed by different philosophers. We find a similar discrimination in the Stoic sources where utterance is said to be different from 'expression' or 'speech' (le/cis) on the grounds that a vocal sound is also an utterance but only articulated speech (to\ e)/narqron) is an expression (le/cis; see Diogenes Laertius 7.57). The more-or-less systematic study of fwnh/ in Stoic philosophy was considered under dialectic and le/cis was regarded as a kind of fwnh/ (Diogenes Laertius 7.44). According to the Stoic Posidonius, a poi/hma is a le/cis in metre or rhythm, i.e. a le/cis going outside prose in its structure (Diogenes Laertius 7.60). Diogenes of Babylon, for example, took the human fwnh/ to be all articulate and sent forth in a deliberate way (Diog.Laert. 7.55). But this specific passage belongs to Philoponus' Commentary on Aristotle's de anima 420b5ff., where Aristotle, after having explained some issues concerning sound and hearing, starts distinguishing utterance from sound. In Aristotle's view, utterance is a type of sound proper to what is animated or has soul in it (e)/myuxon), so for him a name is an utterance (or voice) significant by convention but without time (de interpretatione 16a19-20). With the expression 'by convention' Aristotle refers to the fact that, in his view, no name is a name naturally but only when it has become a symbol (de int. 16a27-28).
[2] i.e. phonetic parts. All animals endowed with such phonetic parts are able to produce some utterance or voice, but human beings are the only ones capable of producing articulated discourse. For, as Aristotle observes, inarticulate noises of beasts reveal something but they do not qualify as names and thereby as a significant utterance (see again de int. 16a28-29).
[3] Trachea, and pharynx which, according to Aristotle, is the organ of respiration (de anima 420b22-23); cf. phi 117.
[4] This assertion is clarified by Aristotle himself: what causes the impact must be also animated (following the mss that give e)/myuxon) and must be accompanied by a certain impression (or representative image: phantasia), for utterance is indeed a significant sound (de anima 420b31-33). Philoponus has shmantikh=s "significant, meaningful" rather than swmatikh=s "bodily." On fantasi/a, see phi 84, phi 85.
[5] The Greek is e)kfw/nhsis, a cognate of fwnh/, and its meaning is almost the same: uttered sound, pronunciation.
[6] In Philoponus the verb is singular, presumably referring to Aristotle.
Keywords: definition; dialects, grammar, and etymology; medicine; philosophy; science and technology; zoology
Translated by: Marcelo Boeri on 11 January 2004@15:14:33.
Vetted by:
David Whitehead (internal rearrangement; initial cosmetics) on 30 September 2002@04:06:17.
Marcelo Boeri on 11 January 2004@15:13:00.
David Whitehead (cosmetics) on 12 January 2004@03:24:01.
Catharine Roth (tweaks and cosmetics) on 3 June 2011@09:01:28.
Catharine Roth (tweaks) on 3 June 2011@22:13:08.
Catharine Roth (tweaks) on 20 June 2011@23:31:25.
Catharine Roth (more tweaks) on 21 June 2011@01:12:18.
Catharine Roth (more tweaks and keywords) on 21 June 2011@17:31:02.
David Whitehead (tweaking; raised status) on 17 December 2013@04:55:02.
David Whitehead (coding) on 31 May 2016@06:37:20.
David Whitehead (my typo; other cosmetics) on 17 June 2016@04:40:20.

Find      

Test Database Real Database

(Try these tips for more productive searches.)

No. of records found: 1    Page 1

End of search