Suda On Line
Search
|
Search results for alphaiota,370 in Adler number:
Headword:
*ai)/tion
Adler number: alphaiota,370
Translated headword: cause
Vetting Status: high
Translation: "The causes [are spoken of] in four ways:[1] as matter, as form, as end, as maker."[2] And of the causes some [are] antecedent,[3] others auxiliary or cooperative,[4] others (?)complete.[5]
Greek Original:*ai)/tion: o(/ti tetraxw=s ta\ ai)/tia: w(s u(/lh, w(s ei)=dos, w(s te/los, w(s poihtiko/n. kai\ tw=n ai)ti/wn ta\ me\n prokatarktika/, ta\ de\ sunerga\ h)\ sunai/tia, ta\ de\ telika/.
Notes:
For the first sentence here cf. John
Philoponus,
Commentaries on Aristotle's de anima 273.8-9 Hayduck.
[1]
Aristotle distinguished four kinds of causes or explanations (
Posterior Analytics 94a21-3;
Physics 194b24-33 =
Metaphysics 1013a24-33;
Metaphysics 983a27-32;
On the generation of animals 715a4-7). The four named here correspond to his, but do not indicate the exact names he used in describing the four kinds of cause.
[2] Or "what is productive of what is produced" (see
Aristotle,
Physics 194b31). Consider a typical example, the causes of a house: bricks and planks (matter); the layout or blueprint (form); sheltering goods and people (end); the architect and builders (maker). The subsequent distinctions are not Aristotelian; they are probably Stoic (see Hankinson, p. 245f.).
[3] Antecedent causes precede in time their effects; the removal of an antecedent cause does not remove the effect. The distinction has major significance in Hellenistic (especially Stoic) discussions of fate and determinism. See Hankinson, pp. 244-247. Galen wrote a treatise
On Antecedent Causes. On Stoic forms of causality see M. Frede (1980), 217-249.
[4] Auxiliary causes contribute to an effect, but do not bring it about on their own.
Sextus Empiricus gives as an example the case of two men lifting a heavy weight with difficulty, and so a third (an auxiliary cause) lightens it (PH 3.15).
[5]
Sextus Empiricus (PH 3.15) gives a different threefold division:
sunektika/ (immediate or containing),
sunai/tia (cooperative or associate), and
sunerga/ (auxiliary). The present term
telika/ may refer to the first of these, i.e. the immediate or containing cause. Alternatively it might refer to the "perfect" (
perfectae) kind of cause also mentioned by
Cicero,
On Fate 41, in connection with "principal" causes in opposition to auxiliary causes.
References:
M. Frede, "The Original Notion of Cause", in M. Schofield, M. Burnyeat, J. Barnes (eds.), Doubt and Dogmatism. Studies in Hellenistic Epistemology. Oxford, 1980, 217-249
R.J. Hankinson. Cause and Explanation in Ancient Greek Thought. Oxford, 1998
Keywords: definition; philosophy; science and technology
Translated by: Monte Johnson on 8 October 2002@16:32:18.
Vetted by:
No. of records found: 1
Page 1
End of search