Surnamed 'Atheist',[1] was a disciple of
Zeno of Citium;[2] he also followed Bryson[3] and Pyrrhon 'the Ephectic'.[4] In holding the doctrine of indifference and transmitting it, he founded his own school, the one named Theodorean.[5] He wrote on many topics, these topics extending towards his own school, and some other themes.
This man said to Hipparchia, the wife of
Crates:[6] '“this is she who left the shuttles of looms” and bears a threadbare cloak.'[7]
Theodôros, ho epiklên Atheos, hos êkroasato Zênônos tou Kitieôs, diêkouse de kai Brusônos kai Purrônos tou Ephektikou. adiaphorian doxazôn kai paradidous hairesin idian heuren, hêtis Theodôreios eklêthê. houtos egrapse polla sunteinonta eis tên oikeian hairesin, kai alla tina. houtos eipe pros Hipparchian, tên gunaika Kratêtos: hautê estin hê tas pros histous eklipousa kerkidas kai tribôna phorousa.
The chronological indicators in this entry are mutually incompatible: some late fifth century BCE, others late fourth century. Either the Suda or its source has conflated two homonyms who should be kept distinct from each other (as they are in e.g. the
Index nominum et rerum of R.D. Hicks' Loeb edition of the principal source used,
Diogenes Laertius). One is the mathematician and geometer
Theodorus of Cyrene (fl. late 5th century BCE), one of the characters in
Plato's
Theaetetus; a former disciple of the sophist
Protagoras, and portrayed by
Plato as an associate of Socrates and the teacher of
Theaetetus; see generally OCD(4)
Theodorus(2). The other, to whom most of the material applies, is the 'Cyrenaic' (Aristippean) philosopher
Theodorus, mentioned briefly in OCD(4) under Cyrenaics.
[1] See
Diogenes Laertius 2.86, 2.97.
Theodorus appears to have written a book
On the Gods, where he positively denied their existence (see Giannantoni 1990, IV H 14-24). This was enough reason to be banished from
Athens. For further data on
Theodorus and his philosophical tenets, see Long (below), 636-639.
[2] The founder of Stoicism: see
alphaiota 4420,
zeta 78,
zeta 79.
[3] Bryson of
Heraclea, a Sophist of the early 4th century BCE. He was criticized by
Aristotle for an allegedly fallacious quadrature of the circle (
An.Post. 75b4;
Soph.El. 171b16, 172a3). In
Physics 185a14-17
Aristotle also stresses that it is the geometer’s concern to refute the quadrature by means of lunes, but not as Antiphon had. 'The circle’s quadrature' is the attempt 'to measure' a circle by means of the inscription of a polygon in a circumference. Antiphon’s method apparently consisted in inscribing polygons with an increasing number of sides. He seems to have thought that, in increasing indefinitely the number of sides, the circumference of the polygon might coincide with the circle’s circumference (see
Simplicius,
In Phys. 54, 12ff.= DK B13 and Heat [below], 221ff.). Both Bryson’s and Antiphon’s attempts are regarded as 'eristic' and not geometrical by
Aristotle.
[4] Pyrrhon of Elis (c.365–275), the founder of Greek Skepticism, called 'the Ephectic' or 'practitioner of suspended judgement'.
Sextus reports that the Skeptical persuasion is 'suspensive' (
e)fektikh/) from the affective state (
pa/qos) that is produced in the inquirer after the investigation (see
Sextus Empiricus,
PH 1.7; 2.9; see also
pi 3241, note 2). He studied under Bryson’s direction (though it is not sure which) and with the Democritean
Anaxarchus, with whom he traveled to India. There he met the gymnosophists and magi who appear to have influenced his philosophical doctrines. Pyrrho wrote nothing, although some of his basic thoughts can be reconstructed from the fragments of his disciple Timon of Phlius (320-230) and from the Skeptic philosopher
Sextus Empiricus. On Pyrrho’s philosophical viewpoints see Bett (below).
[5] For the Theodorean school and way of life see
alphaiota 286, n.9, and
Diogenes Laertius 2.98.
[6]
Crates of
Thebes (368–288), Cynic philosopher (
kappa 2341). When young he became a disciple of
Diogenes the Cynic (412-324; on his philosophical positions see
Diogenes Laertius 6.70-73), and expressed his detachment from wealth by throwing his money into the sea. He, like his teacher
Diogenes, professed cosmopolitanism and followed his mentor’s prescriptions regarding free and public sex in his relations with Hipparchia (
iota 517, and see also
eta 448). He was a teacher of
Zeno of Citium (see note above). Stoicism. On
Crates and Cynicism see Long (below) 629-632.
[7]
Diogenes Laertius 6.98. The core of the quotation -- actually a question ('is this...?') -- is
Euripides,
Bacchae 1236.
R. Bett, Pyrrho. His Antecedents and His Legacy (Oxford 2000)
G. Giannantoni (ed.) Socratis et Socraticorum Reliquiae (Naples 1990), 4 volumes
I.A. Heat, History of Mathematics (Oxford 1965)
A.A. Long, "The Socratic Legacy", in K. Algra, J. Barnes, J. Mansfeld, M. Schofield (eds.) The Cambridge History of Hellenistic Philosophy (Cambridge 1999) 617-641
No. of records found: 1
Page 1